"No man ever steps in the same river twice, for it's not the same river and he's not the same man." Heraclitus
Tuesday, October 1, 2024
Only the US can stop Israel
I detest the Iranian theocracy, which I hope one day will be overthrown by the Iranian people, and I hope that Lebanon will reclaim its sovereignty, with the state asserting its monopoly on the use of force within its borders. So I would never hail Nasrallah as a resistance hero. I also believe that Israel (in its pre-1967 borders), like most nation-states, is a product of history, warts and all, which cannot be erased. Unfortunately, this state is still based on a 19th-century narrative of colonial dispossession of indigenous populations. While criticism of Israel is legitimate, any suggestion of canceling "the entity" is pregnant with genocide.
All that said, what we are seeing today is a far-right Israeli government bent on ethnic cleansing and pushing the region to the brink of 'total war,' led by a Prime Minister who abandoned his own people including the Kibbutz Be’eri on October 7 while his troops were busy 'protecting' illegal settlers in the West Bank, using war to hold on to power. That this genocide (particularly in Gaza where more than 40,000 people have been killed) is happening with US weapons is appalling and risks being Biden's ultimate legacy, even though I hope Americans are wise enough to choose the lesser of two evils, as I cannot even imagine what Netanyahu will do if Trump is elected. The reality is that as things stand Israel can act with complete impunity simply because it has a military arsennal which in the short term, can nuetralise and decapitate any threat. But sustaining this in the long term would further militarise Israeli society turning what started as a social democracy (corrupted from its inception by the occupation and a colonial ideology) in to a fully blown fascist state. Still at this point Harris should know that only the US can save Israel from itself. And the only way to do this is to stop supplying it with offensive weapons and limit military help to the 'iron dome' (even if this raises another question; which iron dome will protect Palestinian civilians in the occupied territories?). But none of this will happen before the Presidential election (and probably even after) not just because of the power of the pro Israel lobby but also because supporting Israel is part of US's national identity. That is not necessarily a bad thing if supporting Israel also entails saving it from creeping fascism. My hope lies in the vibrant Palestinian/Arab diaspora and in progressive Jewish voices, both of which can inject nuance, humanity (and practical common sense) in US foreign policy. They may not be able to stop the carnage happening right now but it could perhaps commence an incremental shift from unconditional support for Israel to a more nuanced approach.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment